» Defenses

D.C. Workers Compensation Act Amended to Provide for Reversion of Third Party Claims

The District of Columbia Workers Compensation Act provides for an automatic assignment of the right to sue a third party to the employer if the person entitled to compensation does not file suit within six months after being awarded compensation in an order. D.C. Code § 32-1535(b). This provision had been…

Requirements to plead a legal malpractice action arising from a criminal matter in Virginia

In Desetti v. Chester, the Virginia Supreme Court considered the issue of whether a plaintiff sufficiently pled a claim for legal malpractice that occurred during the course of an attorney's misrepresentation of the plaintiff in a criminal matter. The plaintiff, her husband, and her son were all involved in a cri…

Federal court in D.C. rejects dramshop liability claims arising from off-premises fight

Partner Steve Schwinn, assisted by Raphael Cohen, of Jordan Coyne, LLP secured the dismissal of all claims against a District of Columbia nightclub owner seeking damages arising from the death of a graduate school student who became involved in a fight outside a fast food restaurant with three men who had been served alcoho…

D.C. Court of Appeals adopts the economic loss doctrine

In Aguilar v. RP MRP Washington Harbor, LLC __ A.3d __ (D.C. Sept. 4, 2014), the D.C. Court of Appeals considered the issue whether the District of Columbia will follow the majority of jurisdictions by adopting the “economic loss doctrine” which prohibits claims of negligence where a claimant seeks to recover…

DC:  Legal malpractice verdict in favor of plaintiff reversed on appeal due to lack of privity

In Scott v. Burgin, No. 12-V-1474 (D.C. Aug. 14, 2014), the Court reversed a $255,000 jury award in a legal malpractice case against a divorce attorney.  The plaintiff was not a client of the defendant law firm, and consequently the Court held that the defendant's duty of care did not extend to the Plaintiff, a…

D.C. Court of Appeals affirms summary judgment based on judicial estoppel

In Atkins v. 4940 Wisconsin LLC, ___ A.2d ___, 2014 D.C. App. LEXIS 192 (D.C. July 3, 2014), the Court affirmed the trial court's award of summary judgment to the defendant on the grounds of judicial estoppel, based on the plaintiff's filings in bankruptcy court in which he represented in his schedules that he…

Premises Liability:  Maryland landowner not in possession or control of the premises

It has long been the general rule of Maryland premises liability law  that a landlord is not liable for injuries to a tenant or third party caused by defects or dangerous conditions where the landlord, or owner, has completely parted with control of the leased premises.  Marshall v. Price, 162 Md. 687, 161 A. 1…
Categories: Defenses, Maryland

Commercial ambulances not shielded by the Maryland Good Samaritan Act or the Fire and Rescue Act

In Murray v. Transcare Maryland, Inc., No. 1791, Sept. Term 2010 (Feb. 9, 2012), the Court of Special Appeals held that a private for-profit ambulance service is not subject to Maryland’s Good Samaritan Act (Md. Courts and Jud Code Ann. § 5-603) or to the Fire and Rescue Act (§ 5-604).   Both st…
Categories: Defenses, Maryland

Attorney malpractice claims in $100 million D.C. patent malpractice suit survive preliminary motions

In Lans v. Adduci Mastriani & Schaumberg L.L.P., No. 02-2165 (D.D.C. May 23, 2011), the District Court, in a 120-page opinion, denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss an attorney malpractice suit arising out of patent litigation. In this suit, the plaintiffs claim that the defendants’ alleged misdeeds resu…

Maryland upholds use of fair reporting and comment privilege as basis for dismissing defamation suit

In Nicholas A. Piscatelli v. Van Smith, et al., No. 18, Sept. Term 2011 (Jan 23, 2012), the Maryland Court of Appeals affirmed that the reporters published articles in the City Paper, which described Nicholas Piscatelli’s possible connection to a double murder in an unflattering light, were within the protective embra…
Categories: Defenses, Maryland